Difficult conversations with volunteers: how to plan them and handle them well

Ashley Staines, co-founder and CEO of Volunteero

Ashley Staines

Co-founder and CEO

·

·

Lunch and Learn card: Handling difficult conversations with volunteers, with speaker Jenny Whyte, volunteer and involvement lead at Crisis, beside a photo of two people talking over mugs

Share

Share

In short

Difficult conversations with volunteers, about performance, wellbeing or organisational change, go better when you plan them: book time and a private space, stick to the facts and decide which outcomes you’d accept. Jenny Whyte, then at Crisis, recommends using silence, gently returning to the core issue and listening, then following up promptly on what you agreed.

In this Lunch and Learn, Jenny Whyte, who was volunteer and involvement lead at Crisis at the time, shared practical tools for difficult conversations with volunteers: why we avoid them, how to prepare, what to do in the room and how to follow up.

Key points

  • Think of them as important conversations: they feel hard because the topic matters.

  • Avoiding a conversation doesn’t help the volunteer, the team or the people you support.

  • Plan every conversation, with time, a private space, the facts and the outcomes you’d accept.

  • Silence and gently returning to the main issue keep a conversation on track.

  • You’re responsible for how you handle the conversation, not for how the other person reacts.

Watch the full session below, including her answers on long-serving volunteers who resist change and on turning down applicants kindly. Under the video, we’ve summarised the key takeaways.

Why difficult conversations with volunteers matter

Jenny named three common topics: performance, concerns about someone’s health or wellbeing, and organisational change, which can be hardest with long-serving volunteers. People often avoid them for fear the volunteer will leave, but handled well, these conversations improve performance, support wellbeing and show volunteers they’re more than a pair of hands. The same standards apply to volunteers who are also donors, as letting some people off creates a two-tier culture.

How to prepare for a difficult conversation

  • Plan it. Never raise an issue on the spot.

  • Book time and a private space, not a reception desk or open office.

  • Note the facts and stick to them: “your last three shifts started late”, not “you’re always late”.

  • Link it to your values and the role description.

  • Decide what outcomes you’d accept, but keep an open mind: there may be things going on you don’t know about.

  • Be assertive. Clear, firm boundaries mean everyone knows where they stand.

  • Talk it through with a trusted colleague, without writing a script.

What to do during the conversation

Say what the meeting is about when you book it, as a vague invitation can worry people more. Open by acknowledging this may be hard to hear, and match your body language to the subject. Then use Jenny’s favourite tools:

  • Silence. Give people time to think before you prompt.

  • Repetition. If the conversation drifts, calmly bring it back to the core issue.

  • A checklist, not a script. Tick off your key points in any order so nothing gets missed.

Above all, listen. People often know something has gone wrong and may raise it themselves.

What to do after a difficult conversation

  • Complete the actions you both agreed.

  • Book any follow-up meeting straight away so it doesn’t drift.

  • If it isn’t getting anywhere, pause, but get the next meeting in the diary that day.

  • Reflect on what went well. Confidence grows with practice.

  • If you planned well and stayed factual and sensitive, their reaction isn’t on you. Lean on your manager.

Questions from the session

How do you handle long-serving volunteers who resist change?

Stay factual: explain the policy, why it exists and that it’s an organisational decision. In Jenny’s view, the goal isn’t to keep every volunteer at all costs but to have the right volunteers in the right roles, and sometimes that means some will leave.

How do you turn down a volunteer applicant kindly?

Go back to the role description and your values, and suggest other roles where they could build experience. A kind template email can also point them to their local volunteer centre.

Do volunteers who manage other volunteers need to keep records?

Yes. Even in an all-volunteer group, follow up with a short email summarising what you agreed, to refer back to later.

Keeping a record of what you agreed

In Volunteero, each volunteer’s profile holds notes and a full history of their involvement, including messages sent and received. Secure in-app chat makes it easy to follow up a conversation in writing. Book a demo to see how it works.

Related reading

About Jenny

At the time of the session, Jenny Whyte was volunteer and involvement lead at Crisis, with more than 15 years in the voluntary sector, including helping a vet school train students in difficult conversations with clients.

Ashley Staines, co-founder and CEO of Volunteero
Ashley Staines, co-founder and CEO of Volunteero

Written by

Co-founder and CEO

Ashley Staines is the co-founder and CEO of Volunteero. After seven years in investment banking, he started it to make volunteering easier to organise.